There's a ton of factors we need to know. Are they older or younger? Is Charles in his wheelchair yet? Does Erik have on his helmet?
I think people tried to compare it to the comics far too much and that's why a lot of people disliked it. The movie was excellently cast, everyone from Sabretooth to Gambit had the perfect actor. Accents were spot-on. We got awesome scenes like the credits through the wars and Logan first encountering Gambit. We also got to see some of the lesser known characters such as Chris Bradley and John Wraith, even if it was just for a bit. Getting to see Ryan Reynolds showing off his skills as Deadpool was also a win. Sure, it had its flaws like all movies do, but it was overall a good film in my book. It showed a very human side of Logan and had a lot of genuinely good scenes.
Both were terrific movies.